OPINION PIECE | FROM BEBOP TO BOOM BAP: JAZZ AND HIP-HOP’S FAMILY RESEMBLANCE

From Harlem’s piano battles to Bronx MCs, Thel­o­ni­ous Monk’s eccent­ric melod­ies to MF DOOM’s intric­ate rhymes, an explor­a­tion of the sur­pris­ing music­al kin­ship between jazz and hip-hop, and the dif­fer­ences that make each an art form in its own right.

There was a time when jazz was con­sidered dan­ger­ous music. It encour­aged promis­cu­ity, cor­rup­ted the young, offen­ded respect­able soci­ety and was appar­ently respons­ible for the impend­ing col­lapse of civil­isa­tion. These days, its devotees are more likely to be accused of own­ing too many expens­ive records and bor­ing people at din­ner parties. Some­where along the way, the devil’s music acquired a uni­ver­sity degree and a wine sub­scrip­tion. Hip-hop, mean­while, has spent much of its exist­ence endur­ing remark­ably sim­il­ar accus­a­tions. Too loud, too vul­gar, too aggress­ive, too Black. Appar­ently, civil­isa­tion has been on the verge of col­lapse for well over a cen­tury, and Black musi­cians keep provid­ing the soundtrack.

As a devoted jazz enthu­si­ast and an equally com­mit­ted hip-hop obsess­ive, I’ve long been fas­cin­ated by the sim­il­ar­it­ies between these two music­al cul­tures. Not simply their shared music­al vocab­u­lary, or the jazz records that have enjoyed second lives through hip-hop sampling, but some­thing more fun­da­ment­al. The atti­tude, the swag­ger, the ingenu­ity, the com­pet­it­ive spir­it and the determ­in­a­tion to cre­ate some­thing excep­tion­al from cir­cum­stances that were often any­thing but.

Jazz and hip-hop emerged dec­ades apart, in dif­fer­ent cit­ies, under dif­fer­ent social con­di­tions, yet they seem to speak a remark­ably sim­il­ar cul­tur­al lan­guage. The more I exam­ine their his­tor­ies, the more I won­der wheth­er jazz wasn’t, in some respects, hip-hop before hip-hop existed.

Before Jazz Learned to Behave

To under­stand why, we need to return to a time before jazz became syn­onym­ous with soph­ist­ic­a­tion and intel­lec­tu­al refine­ment. Before it was music to sit quietly and appre­ci­ate, it was music to get up and dance to. Emer­ging around the turn of the twen­ti­eth cen­tury, par­tic­u­larly in the Afric­an Amer­ic­an com­munit­ies of New Orleans, jazz grew from a col­li­sion of blues, rag­time, brass-band tra­di­tions, spir­ituals and Carib­bean influ­ences. It was music shaped by work­ing musi­cians, com­munity gath­er­ings, parades, funer­als and dance floors, not dreamt up in a con­ser­vatoire. Louis Arm­strong, Sid­ney Bechet and Jelly Roll Mor­ton helped trans­form these tra­di­tions into an increas­ingly soph­ist­ic­ated music­al lan­guage, one in which per­son­al­ity and impro­visa­tion could become as import­ant as the com­pos­i­tion itself. The music was joy­ous, unpre­dict­able and fre­quently glor­i­ously unruly. It belonged as much to the people dan­cing as to those performing.

Fast-for­ward to the Bronx in the 1970s and anoth­er music­al cul­ture was emer­ging from its sur­round­ings. Against a back­drop of eco­nom­ic decline, dis­in­vest­ment and racial inequal­ity, young people developed new artist­ic pos­sib­il­it­ies from the resources avail­able to them. DJ Kool Herc exten­ded the instru­ment­al breaks of funk and soul records, allow­ing dan­cers to occupy the rhythms for longer. Grand­mas­ter Flash refined turntable tech­niques, while MCs, dan­cers and graf­fiti writers con­trib­uted their own dis­cip­lines, trans­form­ing parties into a wider artist­ic move­ment. Like early jazz, hip-hop was fun­da­ment­ally social music, developed through exper­i­ment­a­tion, com­mun­al par­ti­cip­a­tion and a determ­in­a­tion to make some­thing ori­gin­al. Nobody needed to explain its cul­tur­al sig­ni­fic­ance to the people enjoy­ing it. They were rather busy dancing.

There is, how­ever, an import­ant dis­tinc­tion. Jazz’s found­a­tions involved musi­cians inter­act­ing through instru­ments, melody, har­mony and impro­visa­tion. Hip-hop developed around recor­ded sound, with DJs dis­cov­er­ing that exist­ing music could be recon­struc­ted into some­thing new. Its ances­try also extends bey­ond jazz, through funk, soul, disco, Jamaic­an sound-sys­tem cul­ture and the con­tri­bu­tions of Carib­bean and Latino com­munit­ies in New York. It would be his­tor­ic­ally lazy to sug­gest that hip-hop simply des­cen­ded from jazz, as though some­body replaced Charlie Parker’s sax­o­phone with a Tech­nics turntable and called it pro­gress. These were dif­fer­ent innov­a­tions, respond­ing to dif­fer­ent cir­cum­stances. But both demon­strated an extraordin­ary capa­city to turn rhythm, per­son­al­ity and ima­gin­a­tion into an entirely new music­al language.

Nat­ur­ally, respect­able soci­ety had opin­ions. In the 1920s, jazz became the sub­ject of some­thing approach­ing a mor­al pan­ic. Reli­gious lead­ers, edu­cat­ors and social com­ment­at­ors wor­ried about its sup­posedly cor­rupt­ing influ­ence on young people, par­tic­u­larly young white people enjoy­ing music asso­ci­ated with Black Amer­ic­an cul­ture. Its rhythms were con­sidered pro­voc­at­ive, its dances inde­cent, and its social envir­on­ment alto­geth­er too per­missive. The racial anxi­ety was rarely far beneath the sur­face. Dec­ades later, hip-hop would find itself con­front­ing com­par­able hostility.

When N.W.A released Fuck tha Police in 1988, the con­tro­versy escal­ated to the point that the FBI wrote to their record label express­ing its objec­tions. By then, jazz had under­gone a remark­able trans­form­a­tion in pub­lic per­cep­tion. One generation’s threat to pub­lic mor­al­ity had become anoth­er generation’s treas­ured cul­tur­al her­it­age. Hip-hop, appar­ently, had inher­ited the job of fright­en­ing the neighbours.

Yet redu­cing either genre to protest music would be a mis­take. Much of early jazz was cre­ated for dan­cing, enter­tain­ment and pleas­ure. Louis Arm­strong pos­sessed an infec­tious sense of humour, while Fats Wall­er could com­bine dazzling tech­nic­al abil­ity with the per­son­al­ity of a man who had arrived at a party determ­ined to enjoy every minute of it. Duke Elling­ton and Count Basie led orches­tras that made soph­ist­ic­ated music­al arrange­ments irres­ist­ible to dan­cers. Sim­il­arly, the earli­est hip-hop gath­er­ings were not organ­ised as polit­ic­al demon­stra­tions. People wanted to dance, impress one anoth­er, enjoy them­selves and escape the dif­fi­culties of every­day life. The Cold Crush Broth­ers weren’t deliv­er­ing policy lec­tures between verses. The idea that Black music must con­stantly explain its social import­ance over­looks some­thing fun­da­ment­al: joy, cel­eb­ra­tion and hav­ing a good time can be valu­able expres­sions of cul­tur­al free­dom in their own right.

Cut­ting Con­tests and Verbal Combat

There is anoth­er strik­ing par­al­lel in the com­pet­it­ive nature of the two cul­tures. Long before MCs battled for suprem­acy, Harlem’s stride pian­ists were par­ti­cip­at­ing in fierce music­al con­tests. James P. John­son, Wil­lie ‘The Lion’ Smith and Fats Wall­er developed repu­ta­tions through their tech­nic­al com­mand, impro­visa­tion­al ima­gin­a­tion and abil­ity to out­play their con­tem­por­ar­ies. At rent parties, where music helped ten­ants raise money, a pianist’s repu­ta­tion could be won or lost at the key­board. Stride itself required remark­able inde­pend­ence between the hands, the left main­tain­ing a vig­or­ous altern­a­tion of bass notes and chords while the right elab­or­ated increas­ingly ambi­tious melod­ic pas­sages. The music­al equi­val­ent of rub­bing your stom­ach, pat­ting your head and sim­ul­tan­eously humi­li­at­ing your oppon­ent. When Kool Moe Dee con­fron­ted Busy Bee Starski at Har­lem World in 1981, his dir­ect lyr­ic­al attack helped redefine battle rap, shift­ing the emphas­is from enter­tain­ing a crowd towards demon­strat­ing superi­or­ity over anoth­er MC. The weapons had changed, but the com­pet­it­ive instinct remained remark­ably familiar.

Jazz musi­cians, it turns out, were boast­ing long before rap­pers made brag­gado­cio an art form. Listen to Louis Armstrong’s aston­ish­ing open­ing cadenza on his 1928 record­ing of West End Blues. Before the ensemble has prop­erly begun, Arm­strong announces him­self with a tech­nic­ally auda­cious trum­pet pas­sage, its dra­mat­ic leaps and cas­cad­ing phrases demon­strat­ing con­trol, ima­gin­a­tion and con­fid­ence. Later, he sus­tains a high note for an almost absurd length of time, as though ordin­ary human breath­ing were a lim­it­a­tion he had decided no longer applied to him. Com­pare that spir­it with Rakim’s per­form­ances on Fol­low the Lead­er, where intric­ate intern­al rhymes, con­trolled pauses and soph­ist­ic­ated rhythmic place­ment trans­formed expect­a­tions of what an MC could achieve. Arm­strong expan­ded the express­ive pos­sib­il­it­ies of the jazz solo; Rakim helped expand the rhythmic and lin­guist­ic pos­sib­il­it­ies of rap. Neither needed to expli­citly announce his geni­us. The per­form­ance made the argument.

Play­ing Out­side the Lines

Per­haps the most fas­cin­at­ing com­par­is­on, how­ever, comes with bebop. Dur­ing the 1940s, musi­cians includ­ing Charlie Park­er, Dizzy Gillespie, Thel­o­ni­ous Monk and Kenny Clarke were devel­op­ing a strik­ingly dif­fer­ent approach to jazz. Parker’s dazzling alto sax­o­phone impro­visa­tions fea­tured intric­ate melod­ic lines, chro­mat­ic passing notes and rap­id har­mon­ic move­ment. Gillespie explored com­plex har­mon­ies and rhythmic struc­tures, while Monk embraced unusu­al inter­vals, unex­pec­ted silences and angu­lar com­pos­i­tions that could sound almost delib­er­ately awk­ward until their intern­al logic revealed itself. Clarke helped revolu­tion­ise jazz drum­ming by shift­ing the prin­cip­al time­keep­ing respons­ib­il­ity towards the ride cym­bal, free­ing the bass drum and snare for dis­rupt­ive accents. Bebop placed enorm­ous emphas­is on indi­vidu­al vir­tu­os­ity, har­mon­ic under­stand­ing and the abil­ity to con­struct soph­ist­ic­ated music­al ideas in real time. Listen­ing to these musi­cians inter­act, one hears both excep­tion­al indi­vidu­al per­son­al­it­ies and a col­lect­ive under­stand­ing of rhythm that allows the music to move with remark­able freedom.

Parker’s 1945 record­ing of Ko-Ko makes a par­tic­u­larly com­pel­ling case for the par­al­lels between jazz vir­tu­os­ity and lyr­ic­al com­plex­ity. Built around the har­mon­ic frame­work of the stand­ard Cher­o­kee, the per­form­ance is a breath­tak­ing demon­stra­tion of how an artist can take famil­i­ar mater­i­al and rad­ic­ally reima­gine it. Park­er nav­ig­ates demand­ing chord changes at extraordin­ary speed, dec­or­at­ing melod­ic lines with chro­mat­ic notes, unex­pec­ted accents and phrases that seem to tumble over one anoth­er before resolv­ing with aston­ish­ing pre­ci­sion. A rap­per such as Busta Rhymes per­forms a dif­fer­ent kind of rhythmic gym­nastics. Listen to Gimme Some More, where rap­id-fire syl­lables and emphat­ic rhythmic accents cre­ate a vocal per­form­ance that seems per­petu­ally on the verge of escap­ing its own momentum. Park­er was impro­vising melod­ic lines over chan­ging har­mon­ies; Busta’s recor­ded deliv­ery was care­fully con­struc­ted around lan­guage and rhythm. They weren’t doing the same thing, but both demon­strated how speed becomes inter­est­ing only when an artist pos­sesses the con­trol to make every moment count. Any­body can play fast or rap quickly. Mak­ing that speed music­al is anoth­er mat­ter entirely.

Then there is Thel­o­ni­ous Monk, a pian­ist who seemed to regard the con­ven­tion­al place­ment of music­al notes as a polite sug­ges­tion rather than a rule. His melod­ies stumble, pirou­ette and occa­sion­ally appear to walk straight into the fur­niture, yet some­how arrive pre­cisely where he inten­ded. I’ve always adored Monk’s refus­al to make things unne­ces­sar­ily com­fort­able for the listen­er. His com­pos­i­tions exploit dis­son­ance, silence, dis­placed accents and melod­ic shapes that delight in defy­ing expect­a­tions. Listen to Bril­liant Corners, a com­pos­i­tion so struc­tur­ally and rhyth­mic­ally demand­ing that its ori­gin­al record­ing had to be assembled from mul­tiple incom­plete takes after the musi­cians struggled to com­plete it sat­is­fact­or­ily. For a hip-hop par­al­lel, I find myself drawn towards MF DOOM, par­tic­u­larly his per­form­ance on Accor­di­on from Mad­vil­lainy. DOOM’s dense intern­al rhymes, con­ver­sa­tion­al detours and unusu­al place­ment of syl­lables cre­ate the impres­sion of a mind oper­at­ing accord­ing to its own private sys­tem. Monk and DOOM approached music­al struc­ture through dif­fer­ent dis­cip­lines, but each pos­sessed an abil­ity to make the uncon­ven­tion­al sound utterly nat­ur­al. Their eccent­ri­cit­ies weren’t evid­ence of tech­nic­al lim­it­a­tions. They were expres­sions of artist­ic control.

It would be a mis­take, how­ever, to recount the devel­op­ment of these music­al lan­guages exclus­ively through the accom­plish­ments of men. Mary Lou Wil­li­ams was a for­mid­able pian­ist, com­poser and arranger whose influ­ence exten­ded from the swing era into bebop. Her har­mon­ic ima­gin­a­tion helped shape the Kan­sas City sound, while her New York apart­ment became a gath­er­ing place for young­er musi­cians explor­ing the pos­sib­il­it­ies of mod­ern jazz, includ­ing Monk, Dizzy Gillespie and Bud Pow­ell. Her 1945 Zodi­ac Suite, com­bin­ing jazz impro­visa­tion with ambi­tious com­pos­i­tion­al struc­tures, provides ample evid­ence that she was an innov­at­or in her own right, not simply a ment­or to more fre­quently cel­eb­rated men. Hip-hop has its own his­tory of women whose con­tri­bu­tions were fun­da­ment­al to the culture’s devel­op­ment. Sha-Rock helped estab­lish the pos­sib­il­it­ies of early MC per­form­ance through the Funky 4 + 1, while Rox­anne Shanté’s lyr­ic­al com­bat­ive­ness demon­strated that battle rap was hardly an exclus­ively mas­cu­line pur­suit. MC Lyte would later bring a dis­tinct­ive com­bin­a­tion of nar­rat­ive pre­ci­sion, author­ity and rhythmic com­mand. These women weren’t merely par­ti­cip­at­ing in exist­ing music­al tra­di­tions. They were help­ing determ­ine what those tra­di­tions could become.

The Voice as an Instrument

Of course, instru­ment­al­ists do not hold a mono­poly on jazz innov­a­tion, and this is where I must indulge my con­sid­er­able weak­ness for jazz vocal­ists. I could hap­pily spend an unreas­on­able amount of time dis­cuss­ing Sarah Vaughan’s har­mon­ic intel­li­gence, Betty Carter’s adven­tur­ous phras­ing or Dinah Washington’s abil­ity to make a lyr­ic sound like an exquis­itely delivered per­son­al insult. Vaughan’s Shulie-a-Bop, recor­ded in 1954, is an excep­tion­al example of scat impro­visa­tion, with the sing­er treat­ing her voice as an instru­ment, con­struct­ing melod­ic phrases and nav­ig­at­ing a blues frame­work without con­ven­tion­al lyr­ics. Ella Fitzger­ald achieved sim­il­ar feats through her for­mid­able scat per­form­ances, devel­op­ing spon­tan­eous music­al ideas with the soph­ist­ic­a­tion of a vir­tu­oso instru­ment­al­ist. To an untrained ear, scat can sound like some­body mak­ing up non­sense words. To a more attent­ive listen­er, the rhythmic inven­tion, har­mon­ic aware­ness and melod­ic devel­op­ment can be breath­tak­ing. Rather like listen­ing to a tech­nic­ally gif­ted MC whose intern­al rhyme schemes and shift­ing cadences reveal them­selves over repeated plays.

The com­par­is­on becomes par­tic­u­larly inter­est­ing when we con­sider the dif­fer­ence between impro­visa­tion and com­pos­i­tion. A jazz vocal­ist invent­ing melod­ic phrases in real time is work­ing with­in a dif­fer­ent cre­at­ive pro­cess from a rap­per deliv­er­ing a care­fully writ­ten verse. Hip-hop has its own impro­visa­tion­al tra­di­tion, from off-the-top cyphers to com­pet­it­ive battles, although the word free­style does not neces­sar­ily mean that every line is inven­ted on the spot. Con­sider Black Thought’s cel­eb­rated ten-minute Funk­mas­ter Flex per­form­ance in 2017, a mas­ter­class in sus­tained rhythmic con­trol, intric­ate rhyme struc­tures and asso­ci­at­ive imagery. Thought sub­sequently explained that he com­mit­ted writ­ten bars to memory, some­times rearran­ging them for a par­tic­u­lar per­form­ance. The dis­tinc­tion mat­ters. Spon­tan­eously con­struct­ing a jazz solo and deliv­er­ing a pre­vi­ously com­posed rap verse require dif­fer­ent kinds of musi­cian­ship, even when both demon­strate for­mid­able rhythmic ima­gin­a­tion. Under­stand­ing those dif­fer­ences makes the com­par­is­on more inter­est­ing, not less.

There are subtler con­nec­tions, too. Bil­lie Holiday’s geni­us fre­quently lay in what she chose not to sing, or pre­cisely when she chose to sing it. Her phras­ing could drift behind the expec­ted beat, allow­ing a lyr­ic to acquire emo­tion­al weight through restraint. Listen to her per­form­ance of Fine and Mel­low on the 1957 tele­vi­sion pro­gramme The Sound of Jazz, par­tic­u­larly the con­ver­sa­tion­al intim­acy of her deliv­ery and the way it inter­acts with the instru­ment­al­ists around her. Now con­sider the lan­guid, almost con­ver­sa­tion­al deliv­ery of Snoop Dogg on Gin and Juice. I am not sug­gest­ing that Lady Day would have been par­tic­u­larly impressed by Snoop’s recre­ation­al activ­it­ies, nor that the two per­form­ances are equi­val­ent in emo­tion­al pur­pose. What interests me is their shared under­stand­ing that rhythm need not be attacked head-on. Some­times the most com­mand­ing per­former is the one who appears to be in abso­lutely no hurry what­so­ever. Soph­ist­ic­a­tion isn’t always about how many notes or syl­lables you can squeeze into a bar. Some­times it is about hav­ing the con­fid­ence to leave space.

The Beau­ti­ful, Dan­ger­ous Myth of the Tor­tured Genius

It is tempt­ing, when dis­cuss­ing musi­cians whose per­form­ances pos­sess such emo­tion­al depth, to go search­ing for explan­a­tions in their private lives. Jazz has developed an unfor­tu­nate myth­o­logy around the suf­fer­ing geni­us, a romantic image of extraordin­ary tal­ent accom­pan­ied by per­son­al destruc­tion. Charlie Park­er died aged just 34 after years of ser­i­ous health prob­lems and struggles with heroin and alco­hol. Dinah Wash­ing­ton, whose extraordin­ary abil­ity to loc­ate the emo­tion­al centre of a song remains one of the great pleas­ures of jazz singing, died at 39 from an acci­dent­al over­dose involving the bar­bit­ur­ates seco­bar­bit­al and amo­bar­bit­al. Hip-hop has exper­i­enced its own dev­ast­at­ing losses, includ­ing Mac Miller, who died aged 26 from acci­dent­al mixed drug tox­icity. It is easy to con­struct a nar­rat­ive in which suf­fer­ing becomes some neces­sary ingredi­ent of music­al bril­liance, but I find that idea both troub­ling and rather insult­ing to the artists them­selves. Washington’s abil­ity to make heart­break sound almost tan­gible did not ori­gin­ate in a pre­scrip­tion bottle, any more than Parker’s har­mon­ic ima­gin­a­tion was a gift from heroin. Their musi­cian­ship came from tal­ent, dis­cip­line, exper­i­ence and an extraordin­ary under­stand­ing of their craft. Pain may influ­ence what an artist chooses to express, but it should nev­er become the price we expect them to pay for express­ing it.

Bor­rowed Sounds, New Conversations

And speak­ing of the rela­tion­ship between feel­ing and music­al expres­sion, we can­not dis­cuss rhythm without arriv­ing at J Dilla, one of the most com­pel­ling bridges between jazz sens­ib­il­ity and hip-hop pro­duc­tion. Tra­di­tion­al drum pro­gram­ming often encour­ages math­em­at­ic­al pre­ci­sion, with indi­vidu­al sounds aligned neatly to an elec­tron­ic grid. Dilla under­stood that rhythm could be manip­u­lated far more ima­gin­at­ively. His 1995 pro­duc­tion of The Pharcyde’s Run­nin’ also offers a won­der­ful example of his ear for unex­pec­ted source mater­i­al. The track draws its dis­tinct­ive gui­tar fig­ure from Saudade Vem Cor­rendo, a 1963 record­ing by sax­o­phon­ist Stan Getz and Brazili­an gui­tar­ist Luiz Bon­fá, while incor­por­at­ing ele­ments of Woody Her­man and Run-DMC. It’s an ingeni­ous music­al col­lage, assembled from record­ings that might oth­er­wise have remained com­fort­ably sep­ar­ated by genre and gen­er­a­tion. Else­where in Dilla’s work, drums could sit delib­er­ately ahead of or behind expec­ted pos­i­tions, with straight and swung rhythmic feels pulling against one anoth­er to cre­ate a groove that was loose without being care­less. His approach is some­times sim­pli­fied to the idea that he merely switched off quant­isa­tion, but that mis­un­der­stands the care and soph­ist­ic­a­tion of his pro­gram­ming. Like the great jazz drum­mers who pre­ceded him, Dilla under­stood that a beat isn’t simply some­where to place a sound. It’s some­where to cre­ate a con­ver­sa­tion. I sus­pect Thel­o­ni­ous Monk would have found him rather interesting.

When the Music Speaks for Itself

Both tra­di­tions also developed con­sid­er­able capa­cit­ies for polit­ic­al expres­sion, although neither should be reduced exclus­ively to that func­tion. In 1939, Bil­lie Holiday’s per­form­ance of Strange Fruit, writ­ten by Abel Meero­pol in response to the lynch­ing of Afric­an Amer­ic­ans, demon­strated the dev­ast­at­ing power of music­al protest. Charles Mingus’s Fables of Faubus attacked Arkan­sas gov­ernor Orval Faubus for his oppos­i­tion to school integ­ra­tion, while John Coltrane’s Alabama, inspired by the 1963 Birm­ing­ham church bomb­ing, com­mu­nic­ated grief and out­rage without requir­ing a single spoken word. Nina Simone, whose for­mid­able music­al vocab­u­lary exten­ded across jazz, blues, clas­sic­al and oth­er tra­di­tions, took a strik­ingly dif­fer­ent approach with Mis­sis­sippi God­dam. Its almost jaunty, show-tune-like accom­pani­ment provides a delib­er­ately unset­tling con­trast to the fury of its sub­ject matter.

There is some­thing wickedly effect­ive about deliv­er­ing an indict­ment of Amer­ic­an racism through music that ini­tially sounds suit­able for a Broad­way revue. The audi­ence might have arrived expect­ing enter­tain­ment, but Simone had oth­er plans.

Hip-hop would devel­op its own polit­ic­al vocab­u­lary through Pub­lic Enemy, N.W.A, Queen Lati­fah, Kendrick Lamar and count­less oth­ers. Pub­lic Enemy’s Fight the Power is par­tic­u­larly inter­est­ing along­side Simone’s work, not simply because of the polit­ic­al con­tent but because of the way the music rein­forces its mes­sage. Where Simone employed the ten­sion between upbeat music­al form and furi­ous lyr­ic­al con­tent, the Bomb Squad’s dense pro­duc­tion sur­roun­ded Chuck D with inter­lock­ing samples, abras­ive tex­tures, vocal inter­rup­tions and rhythmic aggres­sion. Col­trane could express col­lect­ive mourn­ing through instru­ment­al form; Pub­lic Enemy could con­front listen­ers with expli­cit polit­ic­al argu­ment and make the pro­duc­tion itself sound con­front­a­tion­al. Dif­fer­ent artist­ic lan­guages, dif­fer­ent meth­ods, and some­times sim­il­ar mor­al urgency.

When Jazz Met Hip-Hop

The rela­tion­ship between jazz and hip-hop even­tu­ally became more than philosophical.

A Tribe Called Quest under­stood the con­nec­tion par­tic­u­larly well. On 1991’s Excur­sions, Q‑Tip recalls his father’s obser­va­tion that hip-hop reminded him of bebop, before acknow­ledging the cyc­lic­al nature of music­al culture.

The pro­duc­tion rein­forces the idea, reshap­ing mater­i­al from Art Blakey and the Jazz Mes­sen­gers’ A Chant for Bu into a hip-hop groove. Else­where on The Low End The­ory, legendary bassist Ron Carter appears on Verses from the Abstract, bring­ing the sens­ib­il­ity of a musi­cian who had worked with Miles Dav­is into an entirely dif­fer­ent music­al envir­on­ment. Gang Starr col­lab­or­ated with Bran­ford Mar­s­al­is on Jazz Thing, while Guru’s Jazzmatazz pro­ject brought hip-hop into dir­ect con­ver­sa­tion with musi­cians includ­ing Don­ald Byrd and Roy Ayers. Nas’s rela­tion­ship with jazz was even more per­son­al: his fath­er, the cor­net­ist Olu Dara, con­trib­utes the haunt­ing instru­ment­al outro to Life’s a Bitch on Ill­mat­ic. These weren’t simply oppor­tun­ist­ic encoun­ters with fash­ion­able music­al tex­tures. They demon­strated a liv­ing con­ver­sa­tion between generations.

And jazz musi­cians weren’t neces­sar­ily pass­ive par­ti­cipants in this exchange. In the final years of his life, Miles Dav­is developed an interest in hip-hop and worked with pro­du­cer Easy Mo Bee on what became the posthum­ously released Doo-Bop in 1992. The res­ults divided crit­ics, some hear­ing an excit­ing exten­sion of Davis’s rest­less exper­i­ment­a­tion and oth­ers find­ing the mar­riage of trum­pet impro­visa­tion and pro­grammed beats less con­vin­cing. Per­son­ally, I find the will­ing­ness to exper­i­ment almost as inter­est­ing as the fin­ished record. Dav­is had already helped reshape jazz through cool jazz, hard bop, mod­al exper­i­ment­a­tion and elec­tric fusion. By the time hip-hop arrived, the man had spent dec­ades demon­strat­ing a pro­found lack of interest in remain­ing music­ally sta­tion­ary. Whatever one’s opin­ion of Doo-Bop, it is dif­fi­cult to accuse Miles Dav­is of believ­ing that artist­ic cred­ib­il­ity required behav­ing as though the cal­en­dar had stopped in 1959.

Geni­us Without the Halo

Admir­ing music­al innov­at­ors, of course, becomes con­sid­er­ably more com­plic­ated when we exam­ine the people behind their achieve­ments. Davis’s extraordin­ary music­al leg­acy exists along­side a his­tory of viol­ence towards his former wife, the dan­cer Frances Taylor. Charles Min­gus, anoth­er tower­ing fig­ure in jazz his­tory, assaul­ted trom­bon­ist Jimmy Knep­per in 1962, break­ing a tooth and dam­aging the musician’s abil­ity to play. Hip-hop has its own dif­fi­cult reck­on­ings, not least with Kanye West, whose influ­ence on mod­ern pro­duc­tion remains sub­stan­tial des­pite his repeated anti­semit­ic state­ments and pro­mo­tion of Nazi imagery, for which he pub­licly apo­lo­gised in Janu­ary 2026. There is a par­tic­u­larly uncom­fort­able irony in West’s 2013 track Blood on the Leaves, which samples Nina Simone’s record­ing of Strange Fruit, ori­gin­ally a protest against the lynch­ing of Black Amer­ic­ans, and trans­forms it into part of a song con­cerned with fame and a troubled rela­tion­ship. Its auda­city is undeni­able, but wheth­er the recon­tex­tu­al­isa­tion enriches or dimin­ishes the ori­gin­al mean­ing is anoth­er matter.

These musi­cians’ actions were not equi­val­ent, and music­al accom­plish­ment does not grant any­body exemp­tion from mor­al scru­tiny. But both genres leave us con­front­ing an awk­ward truth: artist­ic bril­liance and per­son­al vir­tue are not neces­sar­ily trav­el­ling com­pan­ions. Acknow­ledging one need not require excus­ing the absence of the other.

For­tu­nately, the con­ver­sa­tion between jazz and hip-hop is not con­fined to the records gath­er­ing dust in an enthusiast’s col­lec­tion. Kendrick Lamar’s To Pimp a But­ter­fly brought togeth­er musi­cians includ­ing Ter­race Mar­tin, Kamasi Wash­ing­ton and Robert Glasper, cre­at­ing an ambi­tious work draw­ing upon jazz, funk, soul and hip-hop without treat­ing any one tra­di­tion as a dec­or­at­ive access­ory. More recently, Little Simz’s 2025 album Lotus moved con­fid­ently between jazz, funk, punk and soul, with musi­cians includ­ing Yussef Dayes con­trib­ut­ing to its expans­ive music­al land­scape. The title track, fea­tur­ing Dayes and Michael Kiwa­nuka, is a par­tic­u­larly sat­is­fy­ing example of con­tem­por­ary rap enga­ging with the rhythmic and instru­ment­al pos­sib­il­it­ies of live musi­cian­ship. Simz’s meas­ured but assured deliv­ery sits with­in an arrange­ment that seems to expand and con­tract around her, demon­strat­ing that soph­ist­ic­ated music­al accom­pani­ment need not dimin­ish a rapper’s individuality.

Across the Atlantic, Doechii’s Decem­ber 2024 NPR Tiny Desk per­form­ance offered a rather glor­i­ous demon­stra­tion of what hap­pens when con­tem­por­ary rap encoun­ters a live jazz ensemble. Backed by an all-female band, com­plete with horns and a rhythm sec­tion, she reima­gined BOOM BAP through a jazz arrange­ment while retain­ing the original’s lyr­ic­al con­fid­ence and rhythmic dex­ter­ity. There is an infec­tious pleas­ure in watch­ing a rap­per com­mand musi­cians whose play­ing responds to the shift­ing energy of the per­form­ance. The res­ult feels less like an exer­cise in genre fusion than a remind­er of how nat­ur­ally these music­al lan­guages can com­mu­nic­ate. One sus­pects that the great jazz impro­visers would have recog­nised the pleas­ure of watch­ing an artist take com­plete com­mand of a room.

Back in Bri­tain, jazz has developed its own rela­tion­ship with hip-hop, grime, broken beat and the wider music­al cul­ture of Black Bri­tain. Artists such as Yussef Dayes, Moses Boyd and Ezra Col­lect­ive have demon­strated how jazz’s rhythmic and impro­visa­tion­al tra­di­tions can flour­ish through con­tem­por­ary influ­ences without sur­ren­der­ing their iden­tit­ies. Per­haps nobody embod­ies the rela­tion­ship more dir­ectly than Birmingham’s Soweto Kinch, an accom­plished alto sax­o­phon­ist and MC who oper­ates com­fort­ably with­in both dis­cip­lines. In a 2016 inter­view with I Am Hip-Hop, Kinch described his two biggest music­al influ­ences as jazz and hip-hop, explain­ing that “you can find me hit­ting jazz jam ses­sions one day, and in a Dont Flop Battle the next!” There is some­thing won­der­fully appro­pri­ate about a musi­cian mov­ing from impro­vising over chord changes to test­ing his lyr­ic­al abil­it­ies against anoth­er MC. In the same inter­view, Kinch acknow­ledged the influ­ence of The Phar­cyde, A Tribe Called Quest and De La Soul, along­side Brit­ish fig­ures includ­ing Lin­ton Kwesi John­son, Steve Wil­li­am­son and Court­ney Pine. He also dis­cussed his Fly­over Show in Birm­ing­ham, which cel­eb­rated artist­ic com­munit­ies in areas fre­quently over­looked by the main­stream music industry. Kinch’s career is a use­ful remind­er that jazz and hip-hop are not simply his­tor­ic­al rel­at­ives whose rela­tion­ship ended with a few samples in the 1990s. For some musi­cians, the con­nec­tion is part of their every­day artist­ic vocab­u­lary. They don’t have to choose a side.

Who Gets to Call It Art?

The grow­ing insti­tu­tion­al recog­ni­tion of both genres offers anoth­er inter­est­ing point of com­par­is­on. Jazz, now firmly estab­lished with­in music edu­ca­tion, is taught in uni­ver­sit­ies, pre­served in archives and cel­eb­rated in con­cert halls. Wyn­ton Mar­s­al­is won the Pulitzer Prize for Music in 1997 for Blood on the Fields, while in 2018 Kendrick Lamar received the same hon­our for DAMN., becom­ing the first hip-hop artist to win the prize. Such recog­ni­tion mat­ters, par­tic­u­larly for music­al cul­tures whose cre­at­ive con­tri­bu­tions have not always been afforded the ser­i­ous­ness they deserve. But it also cre­ates an inter­est­ing ten­sion between pre­serving a music­al tra­di­tion and allow­ing it to devel­op. A museum can explain why a par­tic­u­lar record­ing mat­ters; it can­not determ­ine what the next great record should sound like.

There is an uncom­fort­able irony in the way some listen­ers use jazz as a bench­mark of soph­ist­ic­a­tion against which hip-hop is judged. The sug­ges­tion that an MC some­how becomes more artist­ic­ally legit­im­ate by per­form­ing over a double bass and a few exten­ded chords rather than a bru­tally effect­ive drum machine betrays a pecu­li­ar mis­un­der­stand­ing of both genres. Jazz does not pos­sess a mono­poly on music­al intel­li­gence, and hip-hop does not require a sax­o­phone to become soph­ist­ic­ated. Rakim’s rhythmic phras­ing, DOOM’s intric­ate rhyme pat­terns and Dilla’s manip­u­la­tion of time all demon­strate music­al ima­gin­a­tion of a par­tic­u­larly high order. I say this as some­body who is per­fectly cap­able of becom­ing insuf­fer­able on the sub­ject of Sarah Vaughan’s vocal con­trol. Music­al snob­bery is an enter­tain­ing indul­gence until it starts con­vin­cing us that our pref­er­ences con­sti­tute a uni­ver­sal meas­ure of artist­ic merit.

Of course, neither genre can be reduced to one par­tic­u­lar philo­sophy or sound. Jazz con­tains the exuber­ance of Arm­strong, the orches­tral soph­ist­ic­a­tion of Elling­ton, the har­mon­ic adven­tures of Park­er, the spir­itu­al­ity of Col­trane and the rhythmic exper­i­ment­a­tion of con­tem­por­ary artists.

Hip-hop’s land­scape is equally var­ied, accom­mod­at­ing the intric­ate lyr­i­cism of Rakim, the storytelling of Nas, the abstract con­struc­tions of DOOM and the ambi­tious music­al arrange­ments of Kendrick Lamar. Their his­tor­ies are not identic­al, nor should they be. Jazz’s emphas­is on spon­tan­eous inter­ac­tion between musi­cians dif­fers from hip-hop’s extraordin­ary capa­city to manip­u­late recor­ded sound, although neither tra­di­tion is con­fined to a single meth­od. The most inter­est­ing artist­ic pos­sib­il­it­ies often emerge where these approaches meet.

Per­haps, then, the more inter­est­ing ques­tion is not wheth­er jazz was yesterday’s hip-hop, but wheth­er hip-hop is becom­ing tomorrow’s jazz. Will future gen­er­a­tions study Rakim’s rhythmic com­plex­ity with the rev­er­ence cur­rently reserved for Charlie Park­er? Will Kendrick’s record­ings become essen­tial listen­ing in con­ser­vatoires? Will some­body even­tu­ally pay an offens­ive amount of money for an ori­gin­al press­ing of Ill­mat­ic, then spend an entire din­ner party explain­ing why it sounds bet­ter than the reissue?

Actu­ally, that last one prob­ably already happens.

So was jazz really hip-hop before hip-hop exis­ted? Not lit­er­ally, and it would do both cul­tures a dis­ser­vice to pre­tend oth­er­wise. Their his­tor­ies are too com­plex, their music­al tra­di­tions too dis­tinct­ive, and the people respons­ible for cre­at­ing them deserve bet­ter than an overly con­veni­ent com­par­is­on. But listen to Arm­strong announ­cing him­self on West End Blues, Monk rearran­ging our expect­a­tions on Bril­liant Corners, Rakim find­ing pre­vi­ously unex­plored spaces with­in a bar, or DOOM con­struct­ing rhymes that appear to obey an entirely private set of rules. They are not mak­ing the same music. They are demon­strat­ing a sim­il­ar under­stand­ing of what music­al indi­vidu­al­ity can achieve.

And if that isn’t a fam­ily resemb­lance, I’m not entirely sure what is.

The fol­low­ing two tabs change con­tent below.

About Micky Roots